Fidelity vs Wealthfront: Which Offers the Best Investment Solutions?
Fidelity and Wealthfront are two popular investing platforms in the U.S., but they work very differently. Fidelity is a full service brokerage in which you will be able to purchase stocks, ETFs, mutual funds and operate a variety of different accounts. Wealthfront is an automatic robo-advisor that builds and manages portfolios.
Fidelity will better fit you in case you like to select your own investments, and you desire to have numerous tools. Wealthfront is simpler in case you want to invest with minimal effort, automatically and with low maintenance. But, which one should you choose?
We will compare the two platforms in terms of important criteria to help you choose the trading software that fits well in your needs.
Fidelity vs Wealthfront: Comparison Table
| Feature |
Fidelity |
Wealthfront |
| Investment Style |
Self-directed brokerage + optional advisor support |
Robo-advisor automated portfolios |
| Account Types |
Brokerage, IRAs, trust accounts, retirement, etc. |
Taxable accounts, IRAs, limited account types |
| Trading & Asset Choice |
Wide selection: stocks, ETFs, mutual funds, options, many account types |
ETF-based portfolios, automated rebalancing, fewer self-trading options |
| Fee Structure |
$0 on many trades for stocks/ETFs; advisory services may cost extra |
Flat advisory model around 0.25% of assets under management. |
| Minimums |
Low or $0 for many services |
$500 minimum to begin robo portfolios |
| Support |
Phone, chat, and in-person help |
Online support only |
| Best For |
Active investors, those wanting full service and flexibility |
Passive investors who want automation and minimal effort |
Key Difference between Fidelity and Wealthfront
- Control vs Automation: Fidelity offers the option of picking your own investments; Wealthfront constructs an automatic portfolio.
- Types of accounts: Fidelity has a variety of account types; Wealthfront only has taxable accounts and IRAs.
- Fees: Fidelity does not charge commissions on a variety of trades; Wealthfront charges a small fee each year to manage your funds.
- Tools: Fidelity results in the development of research tools; Wealthfront is easy goal-based planning.
Fidelity Pricing & Fees
- $0 commissions on online U.S. stock and ETF trades.
- Options trades: $0 commission + $0.65 per contract.
- Bonds & CDs: New-issue U.S. Treasuries has $0 fee and secondary market bonds costs around $1 per bond
- No account minimums and no maintenance fees for standard brokerage accounts.
- Margin rates: competitive and tier-based; starting around 7.75% depending on balance.
- Mutual funds include no-transaction-fee options and Fidelity's own zero-expense-ratio funds
Wealthfront Pricing & Fees
- Flat advisory fee: 0.25% annually on Automated Investing portfolios.
- No trading commissions, no account opening fee, and no account transfer fees.
- Portfolio-specific fees: S&P 500 Direct Indexing has 0.09% annual fees and Nasdaq-100 Direct Indexing has 0.12% annual charges
- Cash Account: No advisory fee, earns interest based on current APY.
- Stock Investing Account: No advisory fee; ETF expense ratios still apply.
- Minimum to start: Typically $500 for automated portfolios.
Fidelity vs Wealthfront: Investing Style
Fidelity is the best for investors who want to manage their investments themselves. They can select individual stocks, ETFs, mutual funds or bonds and create their own strategy. On the other hand, Wealthfront does just the opposite. Users do not have to select investments by themselves, instead they just have to respond to a few questions and the platform will design a diversified portfolio accordingly. It also rebalances investment automatically so that users do not have to manage anything.
Wealthfront and Fidelity: Tools & Research
Fidelity offers advanced charts, expert market research, stock screeners, and educational content. These tools help users to analyze businesses and to make wiser investment decisions. Wealthfront is not about the research tools but is about automation. The platform focuses more on goal tracking and easy investment planning than profound analysis.
Fidelity or Wealthfront: Account Types
Fidelity provides numerous types of accounts, and that is why it can be used in a variety of needs. You can open a brokerage account, Roth IRA, traditional IRA, 401(k) rollover, HSA, 529 college savings plan and even trust accounts. Wealthfront has fewer types of accounts and is largely limited to the taxable investment accounts and IRA.
Wealthfront vs Fidelity: Portfolio Management and Tax Efficiency
Wealthfront is a clear winner when it comes to portfolio management and tax efficiency. It offers features like daily tax-loss harvesting in taxable holdings and automatic rebalancing of drift between target allocations. While the portfolio management tools are also available in Fidelity, some of these functions might need some higher-level services or manual configuration.
Fidelity vs Wealthfront: Platform Usability
Wealthfront is superior due to its simple and goal-oriented approach. Its application and web interface are focused on automating the investment process. It offers a well-designed and easy to use platform.
Fidelity is very functional and it is loaded with tools which makes it challenging to learn the platform properly. The vast amount of options might be somewhat overwhelming to newer investors on smaller screens.
When to Choose Fidelity or Wealthfront?
| Use Case |
Choose Fidelity if… |
Choose Wealthfront if… |
| You want control over your investments |
You want to pick stocks, ETFs, mutual funds, or bonds yourself. |
You prefer an automated portfolio managed for you. |
| You need multiple account types |
You need 529 plans, HSAs, trust accounts, or advanced retirement options. |
You only need taxable accounts or IRAs. |
| You like strong research tools |
You rely on charts, reports, and analysis for making decisions. |
You don’t need research tools and prefer simple goal-based planning. |
| You’re an active investor |
You want to trade often and customize your strategy. |
You want a passive, long-term approach with minimal effort. |
| You want human or in-person support |
You value phone, chat, and branch help. |
You’re comfortable with online-only assistance. |
| You prefer automation |
- |
You want daily tax-loss harvesting, auto-rebalancing, and hands-off investing. |
| You care about cost efficiency |
You want $0 commissions for trading. |
You are okay paying a small 0.25% fee for automation. |
Final Verdict: Fidelity or Wealthfront
There you have it! The comparison between Fidelity and Wealthfront. Fidelity is great for investors who want flexibility, research tools, and full control over their portfolio. Wealthfront is ideal for anyone who prefers automated, long-term investing with minimal effort. Your best choice depends on whether you want hands-on trading or a simple, hands-off approach.
If you are still confused, reach out to our software experts or the Techjockey Team for a free consultation and personalized recommendation.